My Top 50

[dizzojay]

So, I've been threatening to do this since I saw amberdreams' list last week, and so here is my Supernatural top 50 ...

It was a great exercise to do because beforehand, if you'd asked me what my favourite season was, I wouldn't have been able to say for sure, but this demonstrates categorically that my favourite season by a mile was season three.

Season six is an odd one for me because it's my joint second favourite season.  I always thought that in terms of the main story arc, season 6 was one of the weakest, but it had some of the greatest standalone episodes in it.

Season 14 is shaping up as a great season too - only halfway through, and I already have four favourite episodes in it!

Season 1

1.4 – Phantom Traveller

1.12 – Faith

1.19 – Provenance

Season 2

2.1 – In My Time of Dying

2.11 – Playthings

2.15 – Tall Tales

2.20 – What Is and What Should Never Be

Season 3

3.3 – Bad Day at Black Rock

3.5 – Bedtime Stories

3.6 – Red Sky at Morning

3.8 – A Very Supernatural Christmas

3.11 – Mystery Spot

3.12 – Jus in Bello

3.14 – Ghostfacers

3.15 – No rest for the Wicked

Season 4

4.1 – Lazarus Rising

4.5 – Monster Movie

4.6 – Yellow Fever

4.8 – Wishful Thinking

4.18 – The Monster at the End of this Book

Season 5

5.4 – The End

5.8 – Changing Channels

5.22 – Swan Song

Season 6

6.4 – Weekend at Bobby’s

6.9 – Clap Your Hands if you Believe

6.15 – The French Mistake

6.17 – My Heart Will Go On

6.18 – Frontierland

Season 7

7.14 – Plucky Pennywhistles Magical Menagerie

7.20 – The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

Season 8

8.8 – Hunter Heroicii

8.11 – Larp and the Real Girl

8.13 – Everybody Hates Hitler

Season 9

9.5 – Dog Dean Afternoon

9.23 – Do You Believe in Miracles?

Season 10

10.2 – Reichenbach

10.5 – Fan Fiction

10.6 – Ask Jeeves

Season 11

11.4 – Baby

11.5 – Thin Lizzie

11.8 – Just My Imagination

Season 12

12.9 – First Blood

12.11 – Regarding Dean

Season 13

13.5 – Advanced Thanatology

13.6 – Tombstone

13.8 – The Scorpion and the Frog

13.16 – Scoobynatural

Season 14

14.4 – Mint Condition

14.12 – Prophet and Loss

14.13 - Lebanon

Comments

[roxymissrose.livejournal.com]

Doing this, I was surprised at how not my fav season one was, and how I struggled picking out shows for season 9, even though I remembered it as being one of my favorites.

[dizzojay.livejournal.com]

It's funny how your perception differs from reality. :)

[jj1564.livejournal.com]

I love your choices - and it amused me that S3 was your favourite, as it was the shortest season! It did have some fantastic episodes and A Very Supernatural Christmas is such a classic.

[dizzojay.livejournal.com]

Yes, I was surprised too. I knew I liked Season 1 - 4, but I always thought I liked them to an equal degree!