Um, do you know that they reopened the voting today for another few hours? Apparently they closed it too early; it was supposed to end Thursday at 5 p.m. I saw a post about it at all_spn.

So, I got in there and kept voting, and the final results were:

Jared Padalecki, Supernatural 85.17%
Travis Fimmel, Vikings 14.83%

Kevin McKidd, Grey's Anatomy 19.29%
Misha Collins, Supernatural 80.71%

Jensen Ackles, Supernatural 59.27%
Colin O'Donoghue, Once Upon a Time 40.73%

So, we're still good. :)